A Four Manual Organ for a Few Hundred Pounds

or

Go from this instrument

to this

for £200 to £300   How can it be done?
           ll

At one point in my career, the church at which I directed the music had a 
very tasteful two manual pipe organ the specification of which I give below.
llll
Swell

Geigen Diapason
Stopped Diapason
Viol d'Orchestre
Voix Celeste
Principal
Fifteenth
Mixture
Contra Fagotto
Horn
 


  8'
  8.
  8'
  8'
  4'
  2'
  3 rks
16'
  8'
Great 
lll
Double Diapason
Open Diapason
Violin Diapason
Stopped Diapason
Dulciana
Principal
Wald Flote
Fifteenth 
Mixture
Trumpet
//
//
16' 
  8'
  8'
  8'
  8'
  4
  4' 
  2' 
  3 rks
  8'
Pedal
   ll
Bourdon
Open Diapason
Principal 
Bass Flute
Fifteenth
 
 
 

 

16'   l
16'
  8''
  8'
  4'
 

 

Couplers

Swell Super Octave
Swell Sub Octavet
Swell to Great
Swell to Pedal 
Great to Pedal
Tremulant ' 
 
 

 

////
Although the instrument was built into a chamber on the North side of the chancel, it was so well voiced that the sound was uniform when heard from all points in the nave.  No one could find fault with the combinations of stops, whether pp or ff and irrespective of the coupling of manuals.  Such an instrument was a joy to play in chorus passages of organ works and indeed in the accompaniment of choir or congregational singing.  What I did find somewhat wasteful was the inclusion of a 4' fifteenth on the pedal where the obvious extra rank should have been a 16' trombone.
      lllll 
What one finds lacking is the availability of colours for a solo voice passage.  The Swell can provide the Gedackt and the Fagotto played at the 8ve accompanied by the Great Dulciana.  The Horn (a robust mf with the box open) accompanied by the Great Stopped Diapason alone or with the 4' Flute is another possibility.
    ll
The Great Stopped Diapason and the Wald Flote singly are pleasing quiet solo voices as is the Violin Diapason in the tenor & alto registers.  The Trumpet is very much a chorus reed and has no real nature to make a penetrating impact.  Its solo voice is more in keeping with the more delicate trumpet work necessary in earlier 17th century works, e.g. de Grigny.
      ll
Oh, for a third manual of the choir/positif variety!  But a major extension that this would entail would be economically prohibitive.  Luckily I had the ideal answer - a digital synthesizer.   The one I employed was the Casio CZ1000 although a CZ3000 would have been preferable.  Even today a synth of this nature can be bought second-hand for £200 to £250.
          ll
Much has been written about the pipe organ v. the electronic organ and  I certainly would agree with a fair proportion of comments but certainly not all.   Here are choice observations by Frank Iacino:-
        ll
"Electronic organ speakers do not distribute sound in the same manner as organ pipes. The latter send out sound waves in all directions. Except for very low tones, speakers (including exponential horn types) are directional.

When a pipe organ vibrantly resounds in a large building, the tone is coming from many diverse sources in many different positions. These positions are three-dimensional, and it is this factor that creates the effect of "spatial dimension". This effect causes the sound to appear to be coming from everywhere at the same time. Consequently, the music floods the whole cubic dimension like a tidal wave.
        ll 
When an electronic organ speaks, the tone comes from one or more tone cabinets. The directional effect is quite apparent and produces a "beam effect". This "beam effect" causes the tone to be irregular throughout the auditorium."
      ll
This is all indeed true in synthesized combinations.  A badly amplified synthesized 'full swell' can be absolutely dreadful when compared with a pipe organ delivery.   Nevertheless many 'flue' combinations of electronic design can be enhanced by the number of speakers or a speaker of the Leslie variety which gives a much greater spread of sound to combat the 'beam effect'.   Where the synthesizer triumphs is in the provision of a single timbre, e.g. strings, flute, clarinet & orchestral oboe or a combination of two in a four channel machine, e.g. 8' clarinet and 22/3'nazard of the flute variety.   The placing of the amplifier in the centre of the organ chamber allows the solo voice to issue from the same area as the pipe accompaniment.
     ll
If one wishes further dissertation on the voicing of the organ pipe, the website by Colin Pykett provides a wealth of in-depth technicalities.   In his "How the Flue Pipe Speaks", Colin Pykett gives exactly what is required in voicing:-

1. The rate of the tonal build-up and the change of the harmonic structure as the tone  ////matures.
2. The degree of tonal steadiness and the shape of the harmonic structure
3. The rate of decay and the change of the harmonic structure during the decay process.
      ll
Now this is exactly what governs the program in setting a synthesized voice - the attack of the sound (the transient in organ pipes), the sustain, the decay and the release of the note.  This is termed the ADSR graph (attack, decay, sustain, release). What is added, however, is one complete rank/voice adjusted at the consol to take into account the reverberation in the building.   Would that the pipe voicer had this facility to hand in organ building, thereby cutting both time and costs.

The above graph is laid down step by step for each voice singly or in combination.  One can think of the Casio digital synthesizer's programming mechanism as its own inbuilt computer to manufacture the settings.   As I have already stated, these voices should be built in the church and the organist's ear, as in the skills of a tuner, will force the synth to conform to the attack, decay, sustain and release of the organ pipes with the church's acoustics as a secondary factor.    The volume of each program will depend whether it is reproducing a soft positif combination or a solo tuba.   N.B. The volume of the amplifier will remain constant - it is the work of the synth program to determine the necessary volumes.

Below are a number of settings for the Casio range of synthesizers.  We are concerned with the following basic steps in programming the synth.  All of the settings are displayed on an LCD:-

Parameter Section

1. wave forms

.........a) sine wave - pure tone e.g. bourdon, flutes 8' & 4', piccolo 
//////////////////

.........b) triangle wave - suitable for producing diapason ranks
//////////////////

.........c) square wave - suitable for bass clarinet & clarinet sounds
//////////////////

.........d) sawtooth wave - harsher than the above, suitable for orchestral oboe, cornopean, /////////////horn,trumpets, tuba, trombone, bombarde & contra bombarde
//////////////////

2. envelope settings

.........a) DCO  (digital controlled oscillator) using 1 oscillator per voice allows 8 note
.............polyphony i.e. full chords ; 2 oscillators allows only 4 note polyphony - 4 note
             chords.

.........b) DCW (digital controlled waveform) changes the timbre of the sound over time. 
.........c) DCA  (digital controlled amplitude) decides the volume required.

3. vibrato = the organ tremulant and can vary the rate per minute of vibrato and the depth.
4. octave  = similar to the effect of an organ coupler - raises the pitch up or down one
                   octave.

5. detune  = fine-tuning the note e.g. up a octave and a fifth to produce a nazard 22/3',
                   although
/the synth requires this entry to be 1 octave and 07 notes
                   (i.e.semitones).

The following are a few examples of charts with all the settings filled in to enable the user to find a few voices immediately as starters:- 

//Dulciana 8' 

/
 MODU
LATION <
DET
UNE
>
<
VIB
RATO
>
OCT
AVE
line select
ring
noise
+/-
octv
note
fine
wave
delay
rate
depth
+/-
range
1
off
off

0
00
00
1
00
00
00

0

DCO1

    /
/

DCO2
/ /


/

WAVE
FORM







WAVE
FORM







first
second







first
second







2
0
















.............................................................
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rate
50
 


 
 
 
 
Rate
 /  /  

 




Level
00







Level








Sust/End
end







Sus/End








//DCW 1..............................................................................................DCW 2
//Key Follow: 0...................................................................................Key Follow:

Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rate
70
00
 ///  / /  //  //  //  //
Rate
 ///  ///  ///  //  //  //  //  //
Level
30
00
 //  //  //  // / /  //
Level
 //  //  //  //  //  //  //  /
Sust/End
sus
end
/// /// // // // //
Sus/End
// // // // // /// // ///

//DCA 1............................................................................................DCA 2
//Key Follow: 0................................................................................Key Follow:

Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Step
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Rate
70
00
// // // // / /
Rate
// // / // // // // //
Level
20
00
// / / / / /
Level
 //  //  //  //  //  //  //  //
Sus/End
sus
end
/ / / // // //
Sus/Emd
/ / / / / / / /

-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-

//Flute 8' & Tierce 13/5'with tremulant 

///
MODU
LATION <
 DE
TUNE
>
<
VIB
RATO
>
OC
TAVE
line select
ring
noise
+/-
octave
note
fine
wave
delay
rate
depth
\++/-
range
1 + 2
off
off
+
2
07
00
1
00
53
03
 /
0
 /////
DCO1
/ / / / / / / //
DCO2
/ / / / / / / /
WAVE
FORM 
/ / / / / / /
WAVE
FORM
/ / / / / / /
first
second.
/ / / / / / /
first 
second.
/ / / / / / /
2
/ / / / / / /
 
2
/ / / / / / /
...........................................................................//////
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rate
50
 //  //  //  //  //  //  //
Rate
50
 /  /  /  /  / / /
Level
00
/ / / / / / /
Level
00
/ / / / / / /
sus/end
end
/ / / / / / /
sus/end
end
/ / / / / / /

//DCW 1.........................................................................................DCW 2
//Key Follow: 0..............................................................................Key Follow: 0

Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rate
73
53
50
// // / / /
Rate
73
53
50
/ / / / /
Level
99
85
00
/ / / / /
Level
99
85
00
// // // //  //
sus/end
/
sus
end
 / / / /  /
sus/end
/
sus
end
// / / / /

///DCA 1...............................................................................................DCA 2
///Key Follow: 0...................................................................................Key Follow: 0

Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rate
70
60
 /  /  /  /  /  /
Rate
70
60
           
Level
06
00
   /  /  /  /  /
Level
25
00
           
sus/end
sus
end
     /  /  /  
sus/end
sus
end
           

-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-

//Orchestral Oboe 8'

//
MODU
LATION <
DET
UNE
>
<
VIB
RATO
>
OCT
AVE
Line Select
ring
noise
+/-
octave
note
fine
wave
delay
rate
depth
+/-
range
1
off
off
+
0
00
00
1
00
53
03
+
1
                             //
DCO1
/ / / / / / / /
DCO2
/ / / / / / / /
WAVE
FORM
/ / / / / / /
WAVE
FORM
/ / / / / / /
first
second
/ / / / / /
/
first
second
/ / / / / /
/
3
4
/ / / / / / / // // / / / / / / /
///
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
99
58
00
/
/
/
/
/
rate
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
level
00
00
00
/
/
/
/
//
level
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
sus/end
***
sus
end
/
/
/
/
/
sus/end
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
///
.. DCW1......................................................................................,..............DCW2
//Key Follow:  9............................................................................,............Key Follow:
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
74
00
/
/
/
/
/
/
rate
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
level
99
00
/
/
/
/
/
/
level
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
sus/end
***
end
/
/
/
/
/
//
sus/end
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
///// 
//DCA1..........................................................................................,,............DCA2
//Key Follow:  0..............................................................................,,..........Key Follow:
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
70
60
//
//
//
//
//
//
rate
//
//
//
/
/
/
/
/
level
20
00
//
//
//
//
//
/
level
/
//
//
//
//
/
/
/
sus/end
sus
end
//
//
//
//
/
/
sus/end
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/

-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-

//Tuba Mirabilis 8' 

//
MODU
LATION <
DET
UNE
>
<
VIB
RATO
>
OCT
AVE
Line Select
ring
noise
+/-
octave
note
fine
wave
delay
rate
depth
+/-
range
1 + 2
off
off
+
0
00
00
1
00
00
00
//
00
////////////////////
DCO1
/ / / / / / / /
DCO2
/ / / / / / / /
WAVE
FORM
/ / / / / /
//
WAVE
FORM
/ / / / / / /
first
second / / / / / / /
first
second
/ / / / / / /
3
0
/ / / / / / /
3
0
/ / / / / / /
   //
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
50
/ / / / / / /
rate
50
/ / / / / / /
level
00
/ / / / / / /
level
00
/ / / / / /
/
sus/end
end
/ / / / / / /
sus/end
end
/ / / / / / /
///
//DCW1..............................................................................................DCW2
//Key Follow:  4.................................................................................Key Follow:  4
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
73
53
50
/ / / / /
rate
73
53
50
/ / / / /
level
80
90
00
/ / / / /
level
80
90
00
/ / / / /
sus/end
***
sus
end
/ / / /
/
sus/end
***
sus
end
/ / / / /
     ///
//DCA1.................................................................................................DCA2
//Key Follow:  3 ..................................................................................Key Follow: 
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
70
60
/ / / / / /
rate
70
60
/ / / // // //
level
99
00
// // // // // //
level
70
00
/ / / / /
/
sus/end
sus
end
// // // // //
/
sus/end
sus
end
/ / / / / /

-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-

Clarinet 8' & Tierce 13/5'
   //

//
MODU
LATION <
DET
UNE
>
<
VIB
RATO
>
OCT
AVE
Line Select
ring
noise
+/-
octave
note
fine
wave
delay
rate
depth
+/-
range
1 + 2
off
off
+
2
07
00
1
00
53
03
//
0
 // 
DCO1
/ / / / / / /
/
DCO2
/ / / / / / /
/
WAVE
FORM
/ / / / / /
/
WAVE
FORM
// // // // // /
/
first
second
/ / / / / /
/
first
second
/ / / / / /
/
2
0
/ / / / / /
/
2
2
/ / / / / / /
  //
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
99
/ / / / / / /
rate
50
/ / / / / / /
level
00
/ / / / / / /
level
00
/ / / / / / /
sus/end
end
/ / / / / /
/
sus/end
end
/ / / / / / /
     ////
   DCW 1.........................................................................................DCW2
//Key Follow: 0...............................................................................Key Follow 0
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
99
00
/ / / / / /
rate
73
53
50
/ / / / /
follow
99
00
/ / / / /
/
follow
99
85
00
/ / / / /
sus/end
/
end
/ / / / / /
sus/end
/
sus
end
/ / / / /

///DA1.................................................................................................DA2
///Key Follow: 0.................................................................................Key Follow: 0
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
step
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
rate
70
60
/ / / / / /
rate
70
60
/ / / / / /
follow
20
00
/ / / / / /
follow
20
00
/ / / / / /
sus/end
sus
end
/ / / / / /
sus/end
sus
end
/ / / / / /
   /////
-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-
/////
How may one change a voice with minimum of effort?  To change from a penetrating Tuba, all that is required is to remove all the DCO2, DCW2 & DCA2 settings and reduce the DCA1 level from 90 to 60 thereby finding a far less penetrating and more pleasant trumpet e.g. to use in Handel's "The trumpet shall sound".

At DCA Step 1, the rate = attack / level = volume
////DCA Step 2, the rate = reverberation

When building a reed voice - 
DCW Step 2, rate - the lower the integer, the more reediness in the attack. 
DCW Step 2, level - the higher the integer the more sustained the reedy edge to the tone. 

If one wishes no vibrato on a combination which has vib. inbuilt, simply flick the vib. button.

To return to the Casio CZ1000.   An opening was made in the organ console immediately above the Swell manual, the resulting aperture housing the synth keyboard.  The removed panel could be replaced when the keyboard was not in use and fastened in situ by two clips.   A cable ran from the synth up the nearest pillar to the console, along the top of the rood screen and into the North chamber - all very well hidden.   The 200 watt amplifier was positioned in the centre, not the forefront, of the organ chamber and connected to a nearby socket.
  ll
In this way I now had a third manual or, with the quick changing buttons of the synth, really a third and fourth manual.   Pedal sounds could be produced but these had to be played by the left hand duplicated by the organ pedals while the right hand coped with as many notes as was possible.  The use of the pedal tones, therefore, had to be quite selective, e.g. the final line or lines of a hymn.  The occasional chorale prelude, if of sufficiently sparse texture in the manual parts, allowed this also to be a possibility e.g. the chorale prelude "Vom Himmel hoch, da komm' ich her" by Bach.
        ll
Here now are the combinations that emitted from the synthesizer.   I was asked to do a demonstration recital to the local Society of Organists in Tayside and the members had to confess at the end of the evening that they felt that they had been listening entirely to pipework during the demonstration.   One observation - with all pipework blowing, the synthesized Tuba Mirabilis could scythe through the welter of sound like a great well-honed sword!


                 ll

        ll
CASIO CZ DIGITAL SYNTHESIZERS
                   ll
There is memory bank within the synthesizer marked 'Internal'
and a 'Cartridge' as a secondary memory, very
similar to a computer external flash drive.

As is usual in the organ world, I have given the reeds a red colour


Internal
     /
Solo
  /
1. Flute 8’
2. Concert Flute 4’
3. Tibia 8’
4. Tibias 8’ + 4’
5. Tibias 8’ + 2'
6. Krumhorn 8’
7. Krumhorn 8’ + Nazard 22/3
8. Vox Humana 8'
Cartridge
     /
Positive

1. Dulciana 8’
2. Dulciana 8’ + Salicet 4’
3. Small Open Diapason 8
4. Flute 8’ + Nazard 22/3’
5. Flutes 8’ + 2’
6. Flute 8’ + Tièrce 13/5’
7. Flute 8’ + Septième 11/7'
8. Orchestral Oboe 8’

                 //
              ///
Internal Select
    /
Pedal
   /
1. Large Open Diapason 16’
2. Small Open Diapason 16’
3. Contra Dulciana 16’
4. Large Open 16’ + Octave 8’
5. Small Open 16’ + Gemshorn 8’
6. Contra Dulciana 16’ + Dulcet 8’
7. Large Open 16’ + Fifteenth 4’
8. Small Open 16’ + Salicet 4’
       /
Cartridge Select
     /
Solo: 1 to 4    Pedal: 5 to 8
    /
1. Cornopean 8’
2. Tromba 8’
3. Tromba 8+ Clarion 4’
4. Tuba Mirabilis 8’      lll
5. Trombone 16’
6. Trombone 16’+ Tromba 8’
7. Bombarde 16’
8. Contra Bombarde 32’ +
        Bombarde 16’
////
I have heard that it was said by a number of the congregation following my
leaving St. Mary's that: "The organ doesn't sound the same since Mel left".
Now I don't really know if the compliment was for me or the synthesizer!

At the present time I have a bank of synthesizers, digital and vector,
at home at the west end of 'the office' and here I settled on the
optimum colours of registration in collaboration with the
international recitalist, Michael Bonaventure Tomassi,
for organ works he commissioned me to compose
for the Edinburgh International festival.

Recommended reading:

Sound Synthesis Handbook - Casio CZ Series )   will accompany
Sound Data Book - Casio CZ Series.............   .) your synthesizer

The Casio CZ Book by David Crombie & Paul Wiffen (Amsco/Wise Publications London/New York)

Yamaha Music Synthesizer SY Series - will accompany should you wish a vector synth

The Complete Synthesizer by David Crombie (Omnibus Press London/New York)

-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-

The music heard on this page is Sinfonia (Cantata 29) by Bach,
played by the doyenne of them all and in all ages - the
late and great Jeanne Demessieux who has been
the inspiration of many organists.

It is true that she pedaled
wearing French high heels!!

SITE DIRECTORY